Skip to Main Content

History of Toys

Course guide for AHCS 236

Evaluative Annotations

Evaluative annotations provide a detailed explanation of your information evaluation process. They are required for some assignments. 

Usually, annotations simply explain the relevance of a source to your project---why you used the source, why it's noteworthy, and other comments. At Otis, we have expanded annotations to include details about why you believe---or don't believe---a source is trustworthy. You will be prompted to consider things like the reliability, validity, accuracy, authority, timeliness, and point of view of sources.

Annotations done "the Otis way" encourage you to think critically about any information source. They also help assess your information literacy skills.

Depending on the level of your class and guidelines set by your professor, your annotations should cover 3-6 of these criteria:
Sample annotations

Information Literacy Rubrics

The basic criteria for each level are listed below. Always check your course or assignment's rubric in the Nest.

--Advanced

Junior/Senior Level Competency

C - level Information Literacy

  • Source information ANALYSIS supports the topic and includes FOUR quality sources.
  • TWO adequate annotations of quality sources. Analysis may be from database books, articles, academic/museum/professional websites.
  • Sources must appear as in‐text citations and on a works cited page.
  • Each of the annotations must include all of the following criteria:
    • Author’s credentials related to topic
    • Description of type of source/audience
    • Discussion of purpose/point of view
    • Discussion of currency of the source
    • Description of the author's coverage of the topic
    • Explain why the source is relevant to the assignment.

--Practicing

Sophomore Level Competency

C - level Information Literacy

  • Source information is CATEGORIZED to support the topic and includes THREE well-chosen, quality sources.
  • TWO adequate annotations of quality sources. Analysis may be from database books, articles, academic/museum/professional websites.
  • Sources must appear as in‐text citations and on a works cited page.
  • Each of the TWO annotations must include all of the following criteria:
    • Author’s credentials related to topic
    • Description of type of source/audience
    • Discussion of purpose/point of view
      • Discussion of currency of the source
      • Explain why the source is relevant to the assignment.

--Initial

Foundation Level Competency

C - level Information Literacy

  • Source information is RESTATED to support the topic and includes TWO annotations that may be from books, database articles, or academic/museum/ professional websites.
  • Sources must appear as in‐text citations and on a works cited page.
  • Each annotation must include 3 of the following criteria:
    • Author’s credentials related to topic
    • Description of type of source/audience
    • Discussion of purpose/point of view
    • Discussion of currency of the source
    • Explain why the source is relevant to the assignment.

Otis College of Art and Design | 9045 Lincoln Blvd. Los Angeles, CA 90045 | MyOtis

Millard Sheets Library | MyOtis | 310-665-6930 | Ask a Librarian